Independent printer supply finder

Are XL ink cartridges worth it?

An XL cartridge can cost more to buy and still cost less per printed page. Start with two cartridges of the same colour that your printer accepts, then compare their prices with the manufacturer’s stated page yields.

Calculate the cost per page

Divide the price in pence by the stated page yield. For example, Canon UK lists its PG-545 black cartridge at up to 180 A4 document pages and the PG-545XL black at up to 400. Both figures describe black ink. Use the colour cartridge’s own yield when comparing colour options.

Find the break-even price for Canon PG-545XL

Suppose the standard cartridge costs £13.50. At 180 pages, that works out to 7.5p per page. A 400-page XL reaches the same 7.5p per page at £30. An XL priced below £30 would work out cheaper per page in this example. Substitute the prices you see when shopping.

Account for the pages you print

HP measures yield with standard test pages. A dense graphic uses more ink than a short letter, and an inkjet can use some ink to maintain its printhead between jobs. Use the calculation to compare packs. If you print regularly, the higher capacity can also save a cartridge change.

Printers in this guide

Manufacturer sources